Monday, September 17, 2018

Review: Yaram Hazony, The Virtue of Nationalism, 2018

Yoram Hazony makes the case that anti-nationalism is objectively anti-Semitism. He is the president of the Jerusalem based Herzl Institute. He makes clear in this book that Zionism is Jewish nationalism, which he completely supports.

He demonstrates much more in this masterful work that needs the widest possible dissemination. The Virtue of Nationalism's thesis is much broader than the nature of the Jewish State. It's an in-depth look at the theory, nature and history of the national state and why it's the best form of political order known to man. The author's conceptual framework begins by making the vital distinction between forms of government and forms of polities:
When these questions [on community cohesion] are taken into account, we see that political philosophy is naturally divided into two subjects, one more fundamental than the other. One subject is the philosophy of government, which seeks to determine the best form of government, given the existence of a state with a high degree of internal unity and independence. Prior to this is the philosophy of political order; which seeks to understand the causes of political order and on the basis of this understanding, to determine what are the different forms of political order available to us and which of them is best. (p. 59)
Hazony observes that for various reasons, there is little discussion on the nature of political order, what makes it possible and what form of polity is most desirable. This issue goes to the heart of his argument. He presents a compelling case that the nation-state is the largest form of polity that allows for genuine social cohesion and for civil society to flourish.    

Hazony contrasts the nation-state with the other two most prevalent forms of polities: tribalism/feudalism and imperialism. He discounts tribalism as virtual anarchism and a social dead end. The more sophisticated forms of imperialism are based on some universalist ideology such as Marxism, Islam or medieval Catholicism. All of these universal dogmas require much force and oppression to expand and remain in power. The author observes that ancient Israel was unique as a nation of tribes that did not seek imperial aggrandizement. 

Hazony defines nation as a "number of tribes with a common language or religion, and a past history of acting as a body for the common defense and other large-scale projects" (p. 18). He views such nations as the best form of political organization. He argues that the nation-state is a necessary but not sufficient cause for human freedom and flourishing. He notes that all imperial states are held together by force and are, in fact, dominated by the most powerful nation within the empire. 

The author cites the European Union as a "liberal" empire, dominated by Germany, that is profoundly anti-liberty and anti-individualism. This is because the very nature of empires, of whatever stripe, require the brutal suppression of all dissent to the universalist dogma on which its legitimacy rests. 

The author argues that the nation-state has its origins in ancient Israel. He further argues that its modern origins began in sixteenth century Europe. This is an important point because most "anti-nationalists" evade this historical fact and claim that modern nationalism began with the French Revolution. Needless to say, Napoleon's was a classic empire dominated by France and not an example of the Westphalian state model. The "Enlightenment" reaction to the Revolution was the justification for endless wars of peace:
In Perpetual Peace, then, [Immanuel] Kant argues that the establishment of an international or imperial state is the only possible dictate of reason. Those who do not agree to subordinate their national interests to the directives of the imperial state are regarded as opposing the historic march of humanity toward the reign of reason. Those who insist on their national freedom are supporting a violent egoism on a national scale, which is as much an abdication of sound morals as the insistence on violent egoism would be in our personal lives ... The Marxists' condemnation of the Western national state was joined by a liberal anti-nationalism, which eagerly sought an end to the old order in the name of Kant's march toward Enlightenment. (pp.199-201)
Hazony makes clear that even Kant's "liberal" imperialism results in a viciously tyrannical state at odds with actual liberal governance. 

On the positive side of the ledger, Hazony argues that the nation-state makes many political goods possible, unlike any other form of political order. These goods are: the banishment of political violence to the periphery of the nation-state; antipathy to imperial conquest - see the American "deplorables" hostility to neo-con wars of "nation building;" genuine national self-determination and independence; a competitive political order where nations can learn from others' success and failure. 

The author also notes that a relatively free, peaceful and stable nation-state does require some degree of homogeneity. "Diversity" for its own sake leads to Balkanization and ceaseless internal conflict. The author describes, 
what I have called the internal integrity and cultural inheritance of the nation. And it is these things that tend to be lost as the imperial state expands [or as the decadent "liberal" state's borders are erased]. This is because conquered nations bring their own aspirations, troubles, and interests into the state. And this growing diversity make the state more difficult to govern, weakening the mutual loyalties that had held it together, dissipating its attention and resources in the effort to suppress internal conflicts and violence that had previously been unknown to it, and forcing the rulers to adopt oppressive means of maintaining the peace. (p.113)
Hazony cites the Austrian-Hungarian Empire as a textbook example of this violent, destabilizing process. It is also the fate of Western Europe, the United States and any other state that opens its borders to (mutually) hostile tribes.     

The Virtue of Nationalism covers a lot of theory and history in its 234 pages. It is impressively researched and its citations provide a treasure trove of sources for further study on its topic. One of the book's many virtues is its clear and precise prose. The author exercises great skill in presenting complex political concepts in accessible, enjoyable and jargon free language. I can't recommend this work highly enough. It belongs on the bookshelf of every citizen concerned about his nation's future.

Monday, August 27, 2018

Review: Robert Spencer, The History of Jihad: From Muhammad to ISIS, 2018

For many years Robert Spencer has operated Jihad Watch, which documents Islam's unrelenting war upon the civilized world. He has also written a series of books documenting the fundamental nature of Islam as violent, irrational and incompatible with Western culture. His latest book The History of Jihad from Muhammad to ISIS was published last month. It should go without saying that for decades the Fake News, Deep State and Academic Left matrix have been lying about the nature of Islam and jihad. Spencer's new book sets the record straight and will make the evaders' job even more difficult. 


As the title indicates, this book is a narrative of the jihad that begin with Mohammedan cult's hijrah to Medina in 622 AD. For the next ten years Mohamed set the example of jihad that his followers would emulate for the next 1400 years.  Mohamed's campaigns included unprovoked war, brigandage, murder of dissenters and ethnic cleansing: 
Abu Jahl was beheaded. The Muslim who severed the head proudly carried his trophy to Muhammad: "I cut off his head and brought it to the apostle staying, 'This is the head of the enemy of God, Abu Jahl.'" Muhammad was delighted and thanked Allah for the murder of his enemy ... Ultimately the Prophet of Islam determined that Jews and Christians would no longer be allowed in Arabia at all. "I will expel the Jews and Christians from the Arabian Peninsula," he told his companions, "and will not have any but Muslims." He gave such an order on his deathbed. (pp. 19, 44)
These are the orders and examples being faithfully followed by the "radical" or "totalitarian" Islam of ISIS and al Qaeda and the Saudi Entity. Spencer uses classical Islamic sources for his narrative on the life of Mohamed and the jihad he inspired. It is not the "enemies of Islam," but the Prophet's own followers who documented his blood-lust in the subsequent centuries of the Middle Ages. 

What follows the opening chapter is a rather depressing, endless litany of the Mohammedan Cult's incessant, ruthless and brutal jihad with the rest of the world. Including in the narrative is a much needed myth-busting of the so-called multicultural paradise of Medieval Islam. The dhimmi Other would have been surprised on hearing how good they had it under the Caliphate - just as unfortunates currently living in Moslem majorities countries today are viciously suppressed per instructions in the Koran and Hadith. However, it's a sad truth that today people of civilized nations' must study this history in self-defense. For dhimmitude is what our traitorous elites have in store for us. 

There are two thematic points in the book that deserve highlighting. Spencer performs an admirable service by including the jihad in India in his narrative. If anything, the Moslems were even more murderous in the sub-continent than they were in Europe. Under Islam's reign-of-terror millions of Hindus were murdered or forced to convert and thousands of temples destroyed and desecrated. 

The other vital theme is the fact that treason and division within infidel ranks have always been the jihad's best ally. One such traitor in the early 8th century was Count Julian of Ceuta. According to Islamic documents, Julian made common cause with the jihad in order to exact revenge on a rival for power. His efforts helped inaugurate seven hundred years of jihad in Spain: 
Julian also met with Musa ibn Nusayr and got his approval. Then the traitor provided the Muslims with ships to carry the warriors of jihad across the strait that would not arouse the notice of any Spanish sentries. (p. 78)
Julian's treason is an example that Europe's and Spain's elites are following. According to the sources, Julian gave two of his daughters as hostages in order to obtain an alliance with the jihadists, "Julian had no problem with this and sent Tariq his two daughters; apparently, the prospect of their becoming sex slaves of a Muslim ruler didn't trouble him as much as Roderic's behavior" (p. 78). Sadly, Julian is far from unique in committing treason against civilization for some short-term gain. 

The West's current ruling elite are even more depraved than Count Julian. Our rulers are facilitating the mass importation of jihad rapists and killers. They provide the evidence of their own guilt and evil on a daily basis. The Rotherham rape jihad is just the tip of the iceberg. British authorities ignored these heinous crimes for years. Frankly, this is not just a case of "politically correctness run wild." It's clear that the British traitor-elite hate the British people and have some sick affinity for Islam. The British establishment's ongoing jihad against Tommy Robinson is all the proof required for honest people.
  
Twenty years ago Paul Fregosi published his also excellent Jihad in the West. Almost three years before 9/11 the Baltimore Sun "reviewed" the book on 13 September 1998. It includes this gem of pure Fake News:
Worst of all, "Jihad in the West" sends the message that we should divide the world into an Us and an Islamic Them, which is the kind of thinking guaranteed to make the world even less safe. 
It was Mohammad who divided the world between the "House of Islam" and the "House of War" for all time. This division is a fundamental source for the jihad and the foundation for sharia law. Every honest person who has spent a few hours researching Islam understands this inconvenient truth. Nevertheless, the Fake News traitors keep cucking for Islam. Creatures like journolist Robert Ruby share responsibility for 9/11. They have enabled every jihad inspired murder and rape in the West that has occurred since the World Trade Center was brought down. As Spencer illustrates with many examples, treason within is always far more destructive and dangerous than the enemy without. 

Buy this book in self-defense.



Tuesday, August 7, 2018

How the Ayn Rand Institute (ARI) Subverts Her Message

Over the last two decades the progressive rewriting of Objectivism has been ongoing under the auspices of the institution that bears her name. In 1997 ARI published Journals of Ayn Rand. This work is mainly comprised of Rand's extensive notes made during the research and writing of The Fountainhead and Atlas Shrugged. It did not take long for it to come out that some of her journal entries had been subtly altered in order to change their meaning and emphasis. These alterations were apparently done in order to distort the development of Rand's thought. It should go without saying that such bowdlerization of historical documents is scholarly fraud. To my knowledge, ARI has never addressed or commented on its fraudulent publication. 

The editor of the Journals of Ayn Rand is long gone. But, as the saying goes, personnel is policy. The current crop of ARI thought leaders are continuing in its tradition. The favored technique at this time is the cherry picking of Rand's quotes that best suit ARI's agenda. Rand's views that do not conform to the Current Truth are stuffed down the nearest Memory Hole. There are both small and large examples of ARI's pattern of subversion. I'll provide a few in the following paragraphs. 

Gregory Salmieri is one of ARI's leading academic lights. He's an Anthem Foundation Fellow and has published extensively on Objectivism and ancient philosophy. Last month at ARI's annual conference there was a panel discussion with Jordan Peterson. Peterson's attendance was quite a coup for ARI. The moderator was Dave Rubin. The other panelists were Yaron Brook and Salmieri. Clearly, he is being groomed for bigger things within the ARI hierarchy. 

Salmieri is quite active on social media, particularly Facebook. I assume that most everyone still reading this essay is familiar with the ongoing saga of Sarah Jeong. She's now on the New York Times editorial board. She's also a vicious man-hater and anti-white racist. It is not despite, but because of her bigotry that the Times brought her on board. There have been many people urging the Times to fire this embarrassment. As of this writing, the Times continues to double-down on their newest pet racist. 

Enter Salmieri, who feels the need to perform White Knight to Jeong's racist in distress. On August 3rd he posted on Facebook the following:
However, even if one doesn't define racism as privilege+power, (and I don't), and even if one thinks that members of groups who are or have been racially oppressed can themselves be racist, one can think that instances of racism on their part are less bad and/or more excusable than racism against members of such groups. That's my own view. One of the effects of being a victim of racism (or any sort of prejudice) is that it puts one in a position of always having to be race-conscious (or conscious of whatever feature the prejudice is directed against), and in that frame of mind, it must be difficult to avoid falling into racist thought patterns oneself. So the more someone has been a victim of racist injustice, the more understandable I think it is for them to fall into it themselves, and the more admirable it is for them to overcome it. Consequently, I do judge white racists more harshly than I do black ones. But, of course, Jeong is Asian, so she doesn't fit neatly in either box. Clearly in the nasty posts about white people, she saw herself as fighting back against racism, but whether it's racism directed against blacks, or Asians, or some other group, I can't tell from the tweets alone.*
There are numerous obvious objections to this nonsense. It is standard cultural Marxist boilerplate. Basically, if a member of a minority group is a nasty racist, then it must be the fault of the White Devil. Never mind that she posted hundreds of hate tweets many of which were directed at men. Jeong, of course, is not a victim of racial oppression. Just the opposite, she's a member in good standing of the liberal elite. 

ARI has long ignored and often excused the anti-white racism that is omnipresent on the left. Ayn Rand would be appalled by the Left's overt racism and by ARI's appeasement of it. In at least two of her most important essays, Rand made clear her hostility to "reverse racism" and its appeasers. In 1963, Rand came out in strong opposition to even a mild form of affirmative action and other "civil rights" laws that violated property rights: 
Instead of fighting against racial discrimination, they [civil rights leaders] are demanding that racial discrimination be legalized and enforced. Instead of fighting against racism, they are demanding the establishment of racial quotas. Instead of fighting for "color blindness" in social and economic issues, they are proclaiming that "color blindness" is evil and that "color" should be made a primary consideration. Instead of fighting for equal rights, they are demanding special race privileges. (Quoted from her essay "Racism" in The Virtue of Selfishness)
A few years later, Rand had this to say on the growing cancer of the left's increasing racism:
Today, racism is regarded as a crime if practiced by a majority—but as an inalienable right if practiced by a minority. The notion that one’s culture is superior to all others solely because it represents the traditions of one’s ancestors, is regarded as chauvinism if claimed by a majority—but as “ethnic” pride if claimed by a minority. Resistance to change and progress is regarded as reactionary if demonstrated by a majority—but retrogression to a Balkan village, to an Indian tepee or to the jungle is hailed if demonstrated by a minority. (Quoted from "The Age of Envy" in Return of the Primitive.)
I have no doubt that Rand would be equally appalled by "Objectivist" intellectuals making excuses for the far worse anti-white, anti-American racism that today completely dominates the liberal/left. 

Conservative columnist Michelle Malkin (who is ethnically Filipino) has endured vicious racial attacks from the left for her entire career. Most of her attackers are white. However, Malkin did not become a anti-white racist in response. Maybe, contrary to cultural Marxist dogma, minorities also have free will. Of course, this is the standard treatment for every minority who goes off the Progressive plantation. ARI is completely silent on this issue. Meanwhile, their leading intellectual defends one of the race baiting attackers. And, it's not just ARI and Salmieri. I'll remind readers that just last year The Objective Standard published Andrew Bernstein's truly remarkable article celebrating the "resistance" of Nat Turner.

Rand's views on feminism are legend. One of her most famous, or notorious, statements on this topic is her essay "About a Woman President." In it, she wrote that she would never vote for a woman president. Her argument is that no rational, healthy woman would ever want the job:
For a woman qua woman, the essence of femininity is hero-worship—the desire to look up to man. “To look up” does not mean dependence, obedience or anything implying inferiority. It means an intense kind of admiration; and admiration is an emotion that can be experienced only by a person of strong character and independent value-judgments. A “clinging vine” type of woman is not an admirer, but an exploiter of men. Hero-worship is a demanding virtue: a woman has to be worthy of it and of the hero she worships. Intellectually and morally, i.e., as a human being, she has to be his equal; then the object of her worship is specifically his masculinity, not any human virtue she might lack.
Trump Derangement Syndrome has become so rife at ARI, and in Obleftivist circles in general, that several prominent members/supporters no only voted for a woman president in 2016, but for a certified sociopathic woman. As case in point, just a few days ago Salmieri admitted to voting for Hilary Clinton.* He rationalizes his decision based on the absurd notion that Trump would have been worse than Clinton. For all of their erudition, rationalists like Salmieri have difficulty making real world decisions on social or political issues. With reservations, Rand would have supported Trump for president. 

Ayn Rand's explicit repudiation of and hostility to modern feminism has been largely Memory Holed by ARI. In 1999, Rand's collection of essays on the New Left was republished with additional essays as "Return of the Primitive." Included in it is an essay by Peter Schwartz titled "Gendered Tribalism." It is a scathing commentary on contemporary feminism and why it's cancer. More recently, ARI has been soft soaping any cultural viewpoint of Rand's that would trigger the academic leftists they so desperately seek approval from. 

One interesting distortion of Objectivism is courtesy of ARI's new CEO Tal Tsfany. Earlier this year Tsfany published a children's book Sophie. My review of it can be found at this link. One aspect of the book that I didn't go much into was its insipid post-modern feminism. The book's protagonist is a classic Mary Sue - the list at the link is a description of Sophie. She's an impossible heroine with her very own beta orbiter. There is no man in Sophie's world for her to look up to. 

Sophie's characterization is the opposite of an Ayn Rand heroine. Rand commented that when writing We the Living she didn't think she had as yet the skill to depict her ideal man. Hence, the book's central character was Kira. But, she could and did present how a healthy woman would feel about an ideal man. Kira had two heroes to look up to in the book: Leo and Andrei. Both are destroyed by the Soviet police state. 

In her later mature works, the hero is always a man. The heroine is the woman who recognizes the hero's value. In Atlas Shrugged, Dagny Taggart  had no less than three dominant alpha males to choose between. In Sophie there is no hero. One could argue that's because Sophie was only thirteen-years-old. One should remember Rand's idyllic portrayal of Dagny's childhood. She had her own rather passive male friend Eddie Willers. However, their acknowledged leader was Francisco. 

As mentioned above, there are no heroes in Sophie. In it, Tsfany depicts Americans as largely religious bigots and their passive followers. Rand would never, ever have denigrated the American people and, above all, American men in such a manner. ARI's views on race relations, feminism and the American people are in direct opposition to Rand's expressed views on these topics. 

On the other hand, Rand's off-the-cuff statement on the economics of immigration (on which she was factually and historically wrong) has been elevated to Objectivist canon by ARI. Meanwhile, her explicit statements in formal essays, including her literary theory, (see above) are ignored. (And, does one even need to comment on Rand's similar off-hand remarks on homosexuality?) By what standard is it determined which obscure comments are elevated to Holy Writ and which more formal statements are ignored? The answer seems evident. It depends on whether the statement in question on these social/cultural issues now conform to liberal orthodoxy. 

Addendum: I just came across the following brief video clip from three years ago. In it, Salmieri claims that the notion of "white privilege" has some validity. As with his statement quoted above, this viewpoint is pure cultural Marxism. One aspect of cultural Marxism is its attempt to replace, or at least supplement, the class war with a race war. Its poison must be fought, not appeased. 


David Horowitz's Freedom Center has just published a pamphlet dismantling the anti-concept of "white privilege" by John Perazzo. Description follows: 

Introduction: In recent decades, the Left has gained a nearly monopolistic control of the key institutions that shape the American people’s worldview: the mass media, the entertainment industry, the schools, and many of the mainline churches. Consequently, these institutions have been turned into conduits through which leftist perspectives are transmitted to a highly receptive public. One of these perspectives is the notion that white people are both the cause and the embodiment of virtually every societal ill afflicting our country. Until “whiteness” can be either quarantined or destroyed outright, says the Left, “people of color” will continue to fare less well in school, earn less money, and be incarcerated at higher rates than their white counterparts. All inequalities in these various realms are attributed, by the Left, to injustices orchestrated by white people. By relentlessly banging the drum of “white privilege,” the Left has effectively portrayed race relations as little more than a constant battle between white oppressors and black victims. In this new Freedom Center pamphlet, The Left's War on Whiteness, John Perazzo unveils the colossal deception and ignorance that underlies this worldview.

If ARI wants to contribute to public discourse, this is the sort of work it needs to do. But, it won't. Academic "respectability" comes at a high price. 


*Screenshots of Salmieri's posts:







Thursday, July 19, 2018

The Ruling Elite Hate Us, Want Us Dead and Western Culture Erased

Many will think that this blog entry's title is hyperbole. Before reaching such a conclusion consider to following news article from what's left of England. "Students" (more accurately, Moslem invaders) have erased Rudyard Kipling's "If" from a university wall where it had been recently posted.

This act of vandalism is an excellent metaphor for the ongoing invasion and destruction of Western Europe by medieval savages. This invasion's purpose is to erase Western civilization and replace it with its antipode. The West's evil elites applaud such actions and the replacing of Kipling with Maya Angelou's repulsive doggerel.
Can the Evil Elites be More Explicit?
But it appears that Rudyard Kipling has fallen out of favour with today’s generation of students, after it emerged that his “If” poem has been scrubbed off a building by university students who claim he was a “racist”.

Sara Khan, the liberation and access officer at Manchester’s students’ union (SU), blamed a “failure to consult students” during the renovation of the SU building for the Kipling poem being painted on the wall in the first place.
At Ayn Rand's funeral in 1982, "If" was read by David Kelley. She could never have imagined the depths of depravity to which the West has now sunk. She understood that the Left was out to destroy freedom by any means necessary. She understood that our "liberal" elite are irrational and nihilistic. I don't believe she could have imagined that the Left would import savages to do their dirty work and finish the job begun by the Cultural Marxists. 
“As a statement on the reclamation of history by those who have been oppressed by the likes of Kipling for so many centuries, and continue to be to this day, we replaced his words with those of the legendary Maya Angelou, a black female poet and civil rights activist.”
This is the "multicultural" reality of the West. The current elites have to be overturned. Immigration must be greatly curtailed and all immigration of Moslems must end. The West's very survival is at stake in this war. Make the West Great Again by fighting for it to remain Western in culture. Such an effort will ensure that Kipling's virtues of reason, patriotism, courage, individualism and independence won't be replaced by Angelou's "virtues" of victimhood, anti-white racism and the socialist police-state.

"If" by Rudyard Kipling 

If you can keep your head when all about you
Are losing theirs and blaming it on you;
If you can trust yourself when all men doubt you,
But make allowance for their doubting too;
If you can wait and not be tired by waiting,
Or being lied about, don't deal in lies,
Or being hated, don't give way to hating,
And yet don't look too good, nor talk too wise:


If you can dream—and not make dreams your master;
If you can think—and not make thoughts your aim;
If you can meet with Triumph and Disaster
And treat those two impostors just the same;
If you can bear to hear the truth you've spoken
Twisted by knaves to make a trap for fools,
Or watch the things you gave your life to, broken,
And stoop and build 'em up with worn-out tools:


If you can make one heap of all your winnings
And risk it on one turn of pitch-and-toss,
And lose, and start again at your beginnings
And never breathe a word about your loss;
If you can force your heart and nerve and sinew
To serve your turn long after they are gone,
And so hold on when there is nothing in you
Except the Will which says to them: 'Hold on!'


If you can talk with crowds and keep your virtue,
Or walk with Kings—nor lose the common touch,
if neither foes nor loving friends can hurt you,
If all men count with you, but none too much;
If you can fill the unforgiving minute
With sixty seconds' worth of distance run,
Yours is the Earth and everything that's in it,
And—which is more—you'll be a Man, my son!



Monday, July 16, 2018

Ayn Rand Institute's Elan Journo Again Evades the Central Issue

Elan Journo is a fellow at the Ayn Rand Institute (ARI) and its resident foreign policy "expert." Last month Journo had a book published, What Justice Demands: America and the Israeli-Palestinian Conflict. I haven't read it yet. Honestly, it will probably be some time before I bother. I've read many books on this topic. Despite Journo's claims, I don't anticipate encountering anything new in his book. Last year, I reviewed Journo's edited work Failing to Confront Islamic Totalitarianism. I also reviewed Peter Schwartz's The Foreign Policy of Self-Interest that was published by ARI in 2004. I've read several times Journo's edited anthology Winning the Unwinnable War: America's Self-Crippled Response to Islamic Totalitarianism (2009). Therefore, I'm quite familiar with ARI's position on this issue. 

 
Israel's Border with Egypt

Journo published an article, "Tackling Top 5 Objections to 'What Justice Demands,'" today on ARI's new in house blog. This blog, "New Ideal," is a good idea in that it provides a format for ARI's "experts" to write relatively lengthy pieces on different subjects. It's a definite improvement over "Official Objectivism" long oral tradition. The five objections listed are, First: "Isn't it wiser to walk away?" For America, the obvious answer is "yes." Second: "Isn't it a deadlocked, unsolvable conflict?" No kidding. Third: "Why distinguish Palestinians from the Palestinian movement." Because, it helps evade the conflict's larger context. Fourth: "What about stolen "Arab" land?" Already answered many times for anyone open to reason. Fifth: "How can an atheist back a religious state?" Meaning Israel. That's easy. What's interesting is the atheist's refusal to apply the same standards to other states. 

For real Americans, the first point is clearly the most important. The basic question is what national security issues require extensive American involvement in the Arab-Israeli conflict and/or the Middle East? The answer is that there are no compelling strategic reasons for the massive amount of blood and treasure the USA has dumped in that benighted region. 

Journo answers this objection by pointing out that the Arab-Israeli conflict is a part of Islam's global jihad.
By contrast, a common denominator among Israel’s adversaries across decades is that in their political vision and actual practice, they’re hostile to human freedom and progress. They are dictatorships, monarchies, and theocracies. They are variations on one distinct theme: religious subjugation of the individual ... Standing behind Hamas and kindred groups is a leader of the jihadist movement, the Islamic totalitarian regime in Iran.
True, in part. Note the weasel phrase "Islamic totalitarian" as if jihad and sharia were not integral to Islam from its founding in Medina. As if, the jihadists were not following the example set by their "perfect man" Mohammad. Also note the singling out of Iran. As if every majority Moslem country isn't involved in the jihad to the extent their conditions allow. 
The Islamists rail against American foreign policy, including U.S. support for Israel. But neither an American departure from the region, nor even the cessation of Washington’s backing of Israel, would pacify the Islamists ...
In another essay at New Ideal and in my book, I have argued that their basic objection is that we’re unbelievers, everything we do is an affront, and, in the end, it is they who should dominate, in the name of religious totalitarianism ...
Turning our back to this reality cannot advance American interests, precisely because the conflict is far more than a quarrel between two tribes.
Nor, can one advance American interests by evading the fundamental identity of Islam. The way to advance American interests is obvious if that is one's primary* concern. However, if one's primary concern is Israel's security, then you rationalize America's suicidal "engagement" in the region. 

Japan, Poland and Hungary are filled with "unbelievers" whose existence is an "affront" to the "Islamists." Incidentally, no Moslem or jihadist ever refers to themselves as an "Islamist." It's yet another weasel word designed to evade reality. Unlike the United States or Germany or France or Canada, etc., the Japanese, Polish or Hungarian people aren't subject to incessant jihad attacks that require the creation of a garrison state. The reason for this difference is yet another obvious fact that Journo shamelessly evades. Many countries have imported the jihad. Other countries, not ruled by traitors, have declined to share in the joys of dieversity, jihad and creeping sharia. In other words, Journo's recommendation to Americans is to ignore the real causes of both the global and domestic jihad and continue meddling in the region to their own detriment. As I wrote six months ago on another ARI exercise in evasion,
I think the elephant being ignored in this discussion couldn't be more obvious. The real question is why should civilized Europeans and Americans suffer the likes of [jihadist] Anjem Choudary in their midst? Although an "anchor baby" born in England, the only rational way to deal with the Choudarys is to strip them of their British citizenship and ship them back to Pakistan. In Pakistan the jihadists can exercise their "right" to foment hatred for all infidels. The all too obvious response to the question is "they have to go back if they attempt in any way, shape or form to undermine our liberty and way of life." And, "needless to say, the further immigration of Moslems must be immediately halted."
Nobody employed by ARI can honestly address this issue because doing so requires questioning their no-borders (for America) dogma. The best policy for American security is one of containment for the dar al-Islam. We don't even need their oil anymore, in part, thanks to President Trump. 

Point Two: The jihad has been unsolvable for 1400 years. The jihad is patient. It took nearly three hundred years for the Moslems to wipe out the various Crusader States in the Middle Ages. There is no rational reason to believe that the imperative of jihad has been attenuated since then. 

Point Three: According to Journo, relevant, important and justified generalization is "collectivism": 
If we think of people in collectivized terms, we distance ourselves from the facts of the matter and cloud our thinking. Such a perspective elevates unchosen group membership while depreciating, if not erasing, the real, consequential differences among individuals stemming from their chosen outlook on the world, and their other individual choices. One danger of adopting a collectivized perspective is that it can lead you to assume that everyone within that group somehow thinks alike, and thus fail to evaluate them as individuals.
Since it's not possible to choose the culture one's born into, it doesn't matter. Culture is now a "collectivist" concept. That the Palestinians have "collectively" created a culture of death doesn't matter because there are exceptions. Brigitte Gabriel's response to such drivel remains a classic.


Point Four: Anyone still nattering on about "stolen Arab land" is either ignorant or dishonest, and not worth the time to argue against. 

Point Five: How does an atheist, or any secular minded person, defend the Jewish State? That's an easy one. Of course, Israel is the only decent, free country in the region. This fact doesn't change Israel's fundamental identity as a ethno-religious state. Happily, the religion in question is this-worldly, tolerant and values reason. It is the state of Israel's avowed policy that it will remain the Jewish state. In part, Israel's very selective immigration policy is designed to ensure such an outcome. I have no problem with Israel's immigration policy. Bully for them. 

The contradiction here is ARI's and Journo's hypocrisy and double-standards when it comes to mass immigration into Europe or the United States. According to them, there is a basic human right to migrate into these Western countries. An illiterate El Salvadorian has the absolute "right" to enter the US in order to better his condition. However, a Christian African from Sudan has no such "right" to enter Israel. If Journo really doesn't like Israel being defined as an ethno-religious state, then mass immigration would quickly cure that shortcoming. Christians and Buddhists and Hindus and peaceful Moslems filling-up Israel would solve this "problem" for Journo. Jews would be just another group in the multi-cultural mosaic. And, Israel's economy would grow even faster and the country would become even more prosperous according to ARI's claims on the benefits of mass immigration. Somehow, I doubt that such a policy for Israel will ever be advocated by ARI or Journo. 

Instead, Israel has adopted the sane policy of border walls in order to retain its cultural identity. 



Since Journo gets it either completely or partly wrong on his every selected point, I doubt this book will be of much value  compared to many already written on this issue. 

* Journo was born in Jerusalem. He was raised and educated in England. He is an Israeli citizen. Wikipedia didn't state if he ever bothered to get British or American citizenship. Given these facts, asking where his primary loyalties lay is justified.

Tuesday, June 12, 2018

Review: Edward Cline, Presence of Mind, 2010

Presence of Mind by Edward Cline is subtitled, "A Chess Hanrahan Novel." It is one of four thrillers that feature private detective Hanrahan. Although published in 2010, the series was originally written in the 1980s. In chronological order the four books are: With Distinction, First Prize, Presence of Mind and Honors Due. First Prize was published by the Mysterious Press in 1988. All are now readily available for order online. 

The first book of the series, With Distinction, takes place in a small college town where Hanrahan has retreated from the world. He's essentially "on strike" from a country spiraling out of control. When a philosophy professor is murdered, police chief Hanrahan solves the case. Along the way, he learns a great deal about the causes of the country's problems. At the novel's conclusion, he decides to return to New York City to solve cases involving moral paradoxes.  

Chess Hanrahan deals with some aspect of the "establishment's" intellectual and moral corruption in each novel. In With Distinction it's academia. First Prize deals with the aesthetic vandalism of the publishing profession. Honors Due lifts the rocks covering Hollywood and the stage in order to examine what's underneath. In each case, he solves the paradox of how moral corruption under the guise of "idealism" can and does lead to murder. In Presence of Mind Chess confronts what is now called the Deep State's foreign policy empire. As he explains to a traitorous villain who is selling out the United States to the Russians, 
"I'd like to have been born a hundred years ago, so that as I grew older, I could witness the growth of civilization and enjoy its fruits. But, I wasn't. I have to stand by and watch it being sabotaged and overrun by barbarians in this time. I want to understand why that's happening and, when I can, to try and stop the carnage. Most people either aren't aware that that's what's happening, or they're aware but avert their eyes and minds." I paused. "I'm a thinking man. I don't want illusions." (pg. 137)
It's important to remember the context of the book's era of the mid 1980s. During the post Vietnam Cold War era, the liberal establishment worked overtime appeasing the Soviet Union and selling out the USA at every opportunity. One only has to recall their response to President Reagan's "evil empire" quip or "Tear Down this Wall" speech. For example, there was the media's slobbering love affair with "journalist" and Soviet agent Vladimir Posner. Of course, today the same people (or their evil progeny) are fomenting war between the United States and Russia based on their manufactured election conspiracy.

The media/academia axis manufacturing of a Fake News consensus is hardly new. The indoctrination of the American people with the liberal establishment's propaganda was obvious back in the 1980s. The villains in Presence of Mind utilize all of their vast power and influence to create what they call "cognitive harmony" in order to abolish dissent or thoughtcrime before it can impede their agenda, 
"Tragically, it [society] must also 'shed' those persons whose lamentable circumstances, atavistic perceptions, or premature self-endings caused them to resist their ultimate, necessary and wordless absorption into the whole. As resolution to this dilemma, Ketterling [Foundation] advocated a vigorous program of public education to rectify both predicable and unexpected instances of cognitive dissonance present in the lay citizenry, and the establishment of a science of information interpretation as a branch of public perception maintenance, whose goal would be universal cognitive harmony." (pg. 59)
Such cultural harmonizers existed in the 1980s, just as they do today. For example, there is the British and American media's framing of the persecution of Tommy Robinson and the public reaction in Britain. The narrative is that Robinson somehow interfered with the rape trial defendants' right to a fair hearing. Further, all of his supporters are just "far right" soccer hooligans. Happily, only the usual clueless fools are buying this sad attempt to create "cognitive harmony" based on transparent lies. Meanwhile back on earth, we of cognitive dissonance understand the obvious: Tommy's incarceration is an attempt to cover up the British establishment's complicity with the Moslem rape gangs. It's failing spectacularly. If the recent Italian elections are any indication, the globalist traitor-elite had better get used to much more "atavistic perceptions." 
Actual Fake News Caption: "Yobs swear at police as they call for the release of EDL founder Tommy Robinson from jail"
Chess Hanrahan is one of my all-time favorite fictional characters. Edward Cline has created a fully fleshed-out and believable protagonist solving interesting paradoxes framed in tight plot construction. I won't give away anything else in this review. Buy the books and enjoy some wonderful thrillers.

Friday, June 1, 2018

Western Europe's Murder-Suicide & Tommy Robinson's Crucifixion

I was reading Douglas Murray's important book The Strange Death of Europe last week when Tommy Robinson was arrested for speaking truth to corrupt power. The book thoroughly documents what Robinson's persecution illustrates, that the death of Europe is the result of a murder-suicide pact. Murray's book focuses on the mass migration of Moslems into Europe in the post-war era and the results of this self-destructive policy. 




Murray argues that the damage done to Western Europe's culture and institutions are irreversible. Even if he is wrong on that score, time is running out for the cradle of Western Civilization. He is pessimistic because the European elite remain determined to continue their destructive policies to the bitter end. Although Murray doesn't explicitly say so, it's clear that total destruction is the end point sought by the West's traitorous leaders. As he states his thesis,
I mean that the civilisation we know as Europe is in the process of committing suicide and that neither Britain nor any other Western European country can avoid that fate because we all appear to suffer the same symptoms and maladies. As a result, by the end of the lifespans of most people currently alive in Europe will not be Europe and the peoples of Europe will have lost the only place in the world we had to call home. (pg. 1)
He is describing a process that if inflicted on anyplace other than white majority counties would be characterized as soft ethnic cleansing. And, anyone who doesn't exhibit the required symptoms of the prescribed malady will be declared an Enemy of the State. I don't agree with him that Europe's suicide is inevitable. Eurabia is not Western Europe's fate. However, to avoid self-immolation, Europe's people are going to have to throw off their betrayers and replace them with leaders like Viktor Orban. Hopefully, Italy has already begun this process.

Murray breaks his argument down into two broad parts: the how and the why of Western Europe's murder-suicide. He provides an insightful history on "how we got here." It begins with the standard argument of open-borders types on the need for labor to do the work the natives won't do. As Murray amply demonstrates, allowing large numbers of Moslem "guests" was a solution to a short-term problem with immense long-term ramifications. When the economic arguments for invasion no longer hold up, its advocates move to the "multicultural" position. 

The author spends several chapters describing the situation on the front line Mediterranean countries of Spain, Italy and Greece. These nations were all abandoned by the EU when it came to dealing with the immense pressures of the "migrant" invasion. On the other hand, the EU insisted that these countries must accept whoever washes up on the shores of every island in the Sea. The result has been chaos and growing hostility to the EU from its worst hit victims.

On the question of why the EU and other European elites continue with their suicidal policies, Murray is less cogent. He notes that these elites will jump from argument to argument and from position to position as suits their convenience. He also demonstrates that while talking tough on immigration to their constituents, they just keep the migrants rolling in (much like the USA's bi-partisan traitor class). He gives these destroyers too much of the benefit of the doubt. This is a major blunder for at least two significant reasons. First, it grants a moral sanction - or at least a moral fig leaf - to evil. Such a concession will only benefit evil. Second, it makes it more difficult, if not impossible, to identify the nature of the battle and how to win it. Murray does concede that, 
There are also those of course who so hate Europe - what they are and what they have been - that they are willing for literally anyone to come in and take over. In Berlin during the height of this [2015 migrant] crisis I spoke with a German intellectual who told me that the German people were anti-Semitic and prejudiced and that for this reason if no other they deserved to be replaced. (pg. 270)
He elsewhere observes that, "Today's Australian schoolchildren are taught that whatever its present virtues, their nation was founded on genocide and theft" (pg. 163). This pandemic of hate directed at the West is so widespread and of such enduring duration, that no further proof is required on the evil nature of our current elites. I'm old enough to remember the "celebration" of the 500th anniversary Christopher Columbus's discovery of the New World in 1992. It should go without saying that the "liberal" establishment indulged in an orgy of hatred - hatred of Columbus - hatred of America - hatred of Western Civilization. The haters are not some small minority of academic kooks. They have metastasized. They're calling the shots and setting the agenda.

The author briefly discusses the creation of the English Defence League (EDL) in 2009. The EDL was formed in Luton in response to a jihadist group who protested British soldiers parading through town after returning from Afghanistan. The invaders called the soldiers "baby killers" and "murderers." When counter-protesters arrived, the British police took the side of the invading savages, "while al-Muhajiroun had handed out their flyers of protest in mosques with impunity, the locals opposed to the Islamists were prevented by police from handing out any leaflets" (pg. 238). 

Tommy Robinson was one of the founding leaders of the EDL. For his "crime" of dissent, he has paid a steep price. The official persecution began almost immediately, 
From the moment Robinson started the organization his bank accounts were frozen. He and all his immediate family had their homes raided by police and files and computers were taken away ... At the same time there were constant threats from Islamist groups. As well as repeated assaults by Muslim gangs on the EDL's leaders, there were also serious efforts to kill them. (pg. 239)
This is how they roll on Airstrip One. As most everyone reading this knows, Robinson was recently arrested for reporting on the latest trial of Moslem rape gangs in Merry Old England. The judge hearing the case decided to revive the old Tudor/Stuart tradition of the Star Chamber. Clearly, Moslems are Britain's new aristocracy. Even the lowest of gang rapist welfare parasites enjoy protection. Of course, these professional rape gangs that created tens-of-thousands of victims had the protection of the state for decades. Even after the British government was shamed into action, the protection remains in force. Robinson is only the latest in a long line of victims on this issue. 

In his recent article on Robinson's arrest, Murray hedges with the usual qualifications distancing the writer from the victim's principles. In this case Murray opines, "Robinson wised up slightly [by leaving the EDL], and eventually began to plow his energies into a type of citizen journalism/activism." Further Murray states, "Robinson would not now be in jail if he had not once again accosted defendants in an ongoing trial outside the courthouse." Asking a defendant from a distance what they thought of the verdict is hardly an accost. 

There are other examples of such appeasement in the article and many, many others by people attempting to defend Robinson. Such appeasement is a cardinal mistake, as always. Tommy is a hero. He has placed himself at mortal risk in order to expose child rape gangs and speak out on his country's slow motion murder. He is the hero the West now most needs. He is a man who fights. Britain needs one-million Tommys marching on Whitehall in order to dispossess the traitor class of the British government and nation. This view may seem extreme, and I'm not surprised that even someone as knowledgeable as Murray would balk at such a necessity. 

The reality is that Britain's ruling class from government, to media, to academia, to law enforcement enabled the rape gangs for decades. There is no doubt on this central fact of the scandal. There are even rumors of the traitor class's active participation in the crimes. They are still covering for such criminal gangs and lone wolves. It is in this context that Tommy Robinson should be judged and not by nitpicking whether he violated the color of some egregiously unjust law designed to protect rapists and murderers.

Paul Weston is a rare man who understands the issues and that time is running out on his country. Weston was famously arrested a few years ago for quoting Winston Churchill on a London street. A few days ago he uploaded a video on his country's plight, Tommy Robinson and what is to be done. Please, take the time to give it a listen.