![]() |
| Thomas Nast: Our Standing Army |
Recently I discovered a book due to be published this November 1. Written by a Robert Aquinas McNally, It's title is The Modoc War: A Story of Genocide at the Dawn of America’s Gilded Age. By the way, "Gilded Age" is another all purpose smear term directed at the glorious period of almost pure laissez-faire in the late 19th century. I haven't read this dreck and never will. The title alone demonstrates the author's fundamental dishonesty.
The Modoc were a tiny tribe on the California-Oregon border. Since time immemorial, they had subsisted by raiding, robbing and murdering settlers who passed through "their" territory. During the latter half of the 19th century they numbered around 600 individuals. Apparantly, that's how many identified Modocs are still living in the area. We will leave aside the utter absurdity of imparting the status of nation-state to 600 marauding stone age savages.
In any event, in 1872 the US government decided to force a renegade band of Modocs back to the reservation. This band numbered less than 200 people with an estimated 60 warriors. The Modoc War is one of the most colorful episodes of the American West. Obviously, it is not an example of genocide.
Nevertheless, the academic Left has created quite the cottage industry (on the taxpayers dime, of course) of made-up genocides. The Ur Text for these creatures is David E. Stannard's American Holocaust: the Conquest of the New World. It was originally published in 1993 during a high point in pathological Columbus hate. Published earlier this year is another work that will undoubtedly be assigned in every course on Hating Whitey An American Genocide: The United States and the California Indian Catastrophe, 1846-1873 (The Lamar Series in Western History) by Benjamin Madley and thoughtfully published by Yale University Press. Madley's book has the odor of a reworked dissertation. This is the sort of rubbish one needs to publish in order not to perish in the academia of today.
![]() |
| Thomas Nast: Food for Our Tricky Statesmen and Death to Our Honorable Army |
For reliable work on the American frontier that is not filled with white leftist self-loathing, the gold standard is still Robert M. Utley. For authoritative and objective books on the American Indian consult the works of Francis Prucha. As with many subjects on History and America, use extreme caution when referencing recent products of academic presses. Many departments and scholars today are agenda driven hacks and should be avoided.







