Saturday, March 17, 2018

Review: "Are We There Yet?" Roger Chickering and Stig Forster, 2004. An Example of Bad Historical Revisionism


In the first chapter “Are We There Yet” from A World atTotal War, Roger Chickering and Stig Forster analyze the meaning and development of the concept of “Total War.”  Because of a failure to make certain, vital distinctions in their analysis, the writers do not succeed in their main purpose in defining what “total war” is. The worst part of this essay is the author's egregious moral equivalence between Nazi Germany and the Western Allies. Considering Auschwitz and Hiroshima to be on a moral par is a confession of one's own moral imbecility. 

Not an Agent of Genocide
The authors note that the “hallmark” of total war is the use of military violence against civilians (pp. 11).  One reason for this, the authors recognize, is the full mobilization of a nation’s economy in the pursuit military victory.  This led to the blurring, or ending, of the distinction between combatant and non-combatant during World War II.  The reason for this is generally viewed to be the other defining factor of total war: total economic mobilization.  As the authors state total war requires “the thoroughgoing mobilization of industrial economies in the war effort, and hence the disciplined organization of civilians no less than warriors” (pp. 2)  The authors relate how this led theorist such as Guilio Douhet to conclude that civilians (or at least factory workers) were legitimate targets of opposing military forces.  In the context of World War I trench warfare anything that could break the deadlock and bring the war to a conclusion was considered justified.  Although, it wasn’t until World War II that technology, particularly the long range bomber, made this strategy possible.

The “unpacking” this essay deserves would require a considerably longer paper than space allows; therefore I will only mention a few of the methodological problems and factual omissions of serious consequence.  There are four distinct concepts the authors include in their definition of “total war” that I believe should remain distinct.  These are, 1: The degree of a nation’s economic mobilization, 2: Civilians as primary or secondary targets or as collateral damage, 3: The treatment of POWs or war of No Quarter, 4: Genocide.
 
As the authors note the original definition of total war referred to economic mobilization.  The French coined the terms “guerre totale” and “guerre integrale” for their nation’s total mobilization in the last two years of World War I.  There is obviously no clear line that can be drawn between limited and total war regarding mobilization.  The authors engage in some tedious hairsplitting on whether the United States fully mobilized during World War II and therefore engaged in total war.

The authors cite Maurice Matloff “The Ninety Division Gamble” from Kent Roberts Greenfield volume of the Green Series Command Decisions.  The authors, however, do not provide quotes or statistics to support their position that it’s hyperbole to claim the US totally mobilized for World War II (pp. 7).  I don’t have a copy of Command Decisions handy, however in Strategic Planning for Coalition Warfare: 1943-1944 Maurice Matloff explicitly states that the “ninety division gamble” was the direct result of manpower shortages: “By 1943 the ‘arsenal of democracy,’ as the United States had come to be called, was just beginning to hit its full productive stride…Although increased use of women and Negroes, establishment of longer working hours, and improved efficiency in war plants eventually served to augment production, the manpower situation by early 1943 appeared grave” (Maurice Matloff (1959) Strategic Planning for Coalition Warfare, 1943-1944. Washington D.C.: Office of the Chief of Military History. pp. 113, 116).  The concern was that drafting skilled workers would affect production, which could not be allowed.  And not just for factory workers, in November 1942 Congress gave a blanket draft deferment to all agricultural workers (pp. 116).

Regarding Nazi Germany and total war it should not be forgotten that Blitzkrieg was as much an economic concept as a military one.  Hitler’s purpose was to avoid full mobilization with quick decisive wars and to not get engage in a total war of exhaustion that the German economy could not hope to win. In fact, Nazi Germany did not begin full economic mobilization until after Stalingrad when it was too late.

Chickering’s and Forster’s evaluation of how civilians became targets in total war beginning in World War I and culminating in the Second World War has problems of special pleading.  In their analysis they apparently think it’s irrelevant who were the aggressors in these wars and who initiated this aspect of total war.  They note that nearly 740 German civilians were killed in allied bombing raids during World War I; however they fail to note how many British civilians were killed during the preceding Zeppelin raids (pp. 12).  While discussing the bombing raids of World War II the names Guernica, Warsaw, Rotterdam and London are not mentioned.  This is no small matter in evaluating later allied bombing campaigns.  On July 8, 1940 Winston Churchill wrote a memo to the Minister of Aircraft Production, Lord Beaverbrook, “I look round to see how we can win the war, I see that there is only own sure path,” and that was “an absolutely devastating, exterminating attack by very heavy bombers from this country…” (Their Finest Hour. New York: Bantam Books, 1977, pp. 548).  That both the British people and leaders where willing to go to extremes was motivated and justified by previous German attacks.  As an interesting side issue it should be noted that making a large, powerful democracy desperate and fearful for its continued existence can result in very bad things for the fascist aggressors.  The process of “taking off the gloves” in warfare doesn’t happen overnight and the beginning of it should not be ignored.  

Dresden 1945. Not Auschwitz, Not Even Close
Wars of No Quarter have been fought throughout history.  One example is the Texas Revolution of 1835-6.  General Santa Ana apparently thought of the Texans as rebels and therefore not worthy of the rules of warfare.  At the Alamo he put the defenders to the sword.  At Goliad he had 400 captured Texan soldiers executed.  At San Jacinto the Texans responded by killing hundreds of Mexican soldiers as they tried to surrender yelling “me no Alamo;” they understood.  The Texas Revolution was a “small war” regarding the number involved, however it was a brutal one by early nineteenth century standards.  While both the United States and England participated in Second World War’s total nature, both country’s treated Axis prisoners according to the Geneva Convention.

Lastly, the most troubling aspect of this essay, its “revisionist” view of the Holocaust.  The authors state, “Genocide was the other face of total war…The history of total war was driven by material and ideological forces that culminated respectively in Hiroshima and Auschwitz – in weapons that did not discriminate and policies that did so with a vengeance” (pp. 12-13).  This is an example of the old tactic to “normalize” the Holocaust and the continuing of the “Historikerstreit” or Historians Conflict that began in Germany in the 1980s.  As stated above, Hitler’s purpose was to avoid total war, not begin one.  Hitler’s purpose was not total war but social engineering.  Social engineering doesn’t necessarily require total or limited war.  As the cases of Stalin, Mao and Pol Pot demonstrate.  In fact both Hitler’s and Stalin’s example demonstrate that mass murder as social engineering seriously degrades any war effort through vast wasted resources including, in Stalin’s case, a better part of his officer corps.  As Benjamin B. Weber, in his essay “Shades of Revisionism: Holocaust Denial and the Conservative Call to Reinterpret German History,” details some of the tactics used to “normalize” the Holocaust, including “the intentional denigration of the Holocaust and the Third Reich” (Benjamin B. Weber. (December 1996) “Shades of Revisionism” University of Vermont: History Review Vol 6.

Reducing the Holocaust to another aspect of total war is just what the authors are doing by using Auschwitz and Hiroshima in the same sentence.  Whether one agrees with the dropping of the A-bombs on Japan, and the earlier firebombings, these actions had an identifiable war related purpose, to force the Japanese to surrender.  Auschwitz had no purpose to which even a partially sane person can fathom.  It is not an aspect of total war but as the Nuremburg Tribunal the Holocaust was a Crime Against Humanity. 

Gunter Bischof is the head of Center Austria at Tulane University.  He has also tried to make a connection between the Pacific Theater and the crimes of the SS.  On May 31, 2004 he posted an article at the History NewsNetwork, “The American ‘Good War’ vs. the German ‘Bad War’: World War II Memory Cultures.” Towards the end of the article after discussing the Enola Gay exhibit Bischof states: “While in Germany the veterans’ organization had failed to salvage their selective memories of the killing fields on the Eastern front, in the United States the veterans succeeded in enforcing their one-sided memory of heroic marines and valiant sailors.  Their killing frenzies in the island campaign and trophy taking of Japanese body parts was purged from the public memory.”  The comparison of American combat soldiers in the Pacific with Einsatzgruppen is now apparently acceptable for scholarly discourse.  It should be remembered however, that if “Hap” Arnold and “Bomber” Harris are as bad as Adolf Eichmann and Reinhardt Heydrich: then Eichmann and Heydrich are no worse than Arnold and Harris.  


Friday, March 9, 2018

Review: Hugh D. R. Baker. Chinese Family and Kinship. London: MacMillan Press, 1979.



In this study, Baker focuses on two Chinese concepts that define their view on proper family relationships. Wu-fu means the “five mourning grades,” and wu-lun describes the “five human relationships.”  These concepts identify the social hierarchy of Chinese society. Wu-lun is the more fundamental concept and is based on Confucian precepts. The five relationships are ruler/minister, father/son, elder brother/younger brother, husband/wife, and friend/friend (11). Except for the last, all of these relationships are about status with the latter person as the inferior half. Wu-fu is more complex than wu-lun. Wu-fu was a state sanctioned code of five mourning grades that were based on one’s relationship to the deceased. Wu-fu defined a person’s place within the hierarchy of their lineage. It was directly related to ritual and those who did not demonstrate the correct mourning garb were subject to severe punishment. This was one method by which the state enforced adherence to ritual. Wu-fu codified the web of association in which all Chinese lived, and was so vividly described by Fei Xiaotang. 


Baker does not have a thesis for this work. His book is a description of the Chinese family and its place in Chinese society within the framework of the associated rituals. He states that all relationships in the family are based on a “pecking-order” (15). The “pecking order” that ordains superiority and inferiority in all family relationships is generation, age, and sex. For example, while a husband is superior to his wife because of sex, he is expected to defer to his mother due to her superior generational position. This “pecking order,” along with wu-fu and wu-lun, “makes clear to whom each owes respect and obedience” for every individual in the family or lineage group (16).

Baker applies the above concepts to two traditions within that Chinese family that most illustrate the central important of the carefully defined hierarchies. These traditions are ancestor worship and lineages. Baker quotes a proverb that expresses that function of ancestor worship which places every individual in a “Continuum of Descent”: “he exists by virtue of his ancestors, and his descendants exist only through him” (71). As he explains, death does not end the mutual responsibilities between parent and child. In order to be secure in the afterlife, the dead require the appropriate sacrifices from their descendants, just as the living require blessings from the departed. Descent was patriarchal; hence the Chinese obsession with having a son to carry on the line. Women became appendages to the male line of their family.  

Baker’s chapter on lineages ties in well with Fei’s concept of differential mode of association. Lineages were extended families that held some property in common via trusts. The purpose of these trusts was to finance worship of significant ancestors. All males descended from this ancestor were part of the lineage (49). As Fei had written, these lineages could become states within the Chinese state, especially during the rule of a weak or declining dynasty. They enforced de facto legal codes. According to Baker, lineages were much more common in the south than in the north. While he provides several reasons for this, the impression is given that there is no consensus on this by scholars. This book dovetails nicely with that of Fei.   

Friday, February 23, 2018

Review: Matt M. Matthews, The US Army on the Mexican Border: A Historical Perspective, 2007

It is almost too much to hope that our own border can be protected by American troops. - Washington Post, 15 April 1915
This short, 100 page monograph was published by the US Army's Combat Studies Institute that is located at Fort Leavenworth, Kansas. The Army has made it available at no cost here on PDF format. As the title indicates, this work is mainly a historical review of the US military on the border from 1829 to the present. The bulk of the narrative covers the period from the Mexican-American War to the 1920s. The author makes clear that the change from frontier to border did not occur until well into the twentieth century. 


The book begins with the first peaceful and amicable meeting between American and Mexican troops on the Santa Fe Trail in 1829. It continues with a lucid and well-constructed account of the Mexican-American War. It concludes with a brief account of the military's recent support efforts on the border to interdict drugs. 

The bulk of the narrative deals with the cross border violence that was endemic from the 1840s until after the First World War. During much of the nineteenth century, one of the US Army's main efforts on the frontier were attempts to stop Indian raiders who used Mexican territory as sanctuary. The opposite was also true with Indians in American territory crossing over into Mexico to launch raids. With the final suppression of Geronimo's band in 1886, this mission was complete. 

Most of the book deals with the US Army's attempt to deal with violence that spilled north due to Mexico's chronic political instability and lawlessness. One thing made clear in this work is that only forceful action by the US military has ever prompted the governments in Mexico City to take action against their own criminal border-crossing element. 
[Porfirio] Diaz was mortified and discomfited by the continual American [military] border crossings [in hot pursuit of bandits]. Fearing further damage to his political standing, Diaz was force to act. The Mexican President sent one of his best generals to the border and ordered his army to take aggressive action against raiders and criminal elements in Mexico. By the close of 1878, raids from Mexico into the United States had been greatly reduced. (pg. 53). 
With the death of Diaz in 1911, Mexico was again plunged into political chaos. The violence quickly spread north of the border with an able assist by a meddling President Woodrow Wilson. The vicious attack upon Columbus, New Mexico by Pancho Villa in March 1916 led to General John Pershing's famous Punitive Expedition deep into Mexico. Villa made good his escape. By the 1920s peace had return to the border region. It was during this period that the Army turned over border patrol duties to civilian law enforcement agencies. 


Since the 1960s, lawlessness, violence and massive illegal invasion has become the norm again on America's southern border. As with terrorism, the "law enforcement" model has largely failed. One major reason for both failures is the refusal of Washington to acknowledge the nature of the problem. The main source of the massive border problem is both the Mexican government's and American elite's contempt for American national sovereignty and rights. For example, while the media obsesses about alleged Russian influence on the last election, the government of Mexico openly interferes in American politics - including during the election. And nobody cares; it is reported as business as usual. 

Take the time to read this short work in order to gain a more complete understanding of America's current border crisis. 

Friday, February 2, 2018

Review: Bob Drury & Tom Clavin, Lucky 666: The Impossible Mission. 2016

I'm deeply thankful that Bob Drury and Tom Clavin have thoroughly researched and told the story of the crew of Lucky 666: The Impossible Mission. Old 666 was a B-17 Flying Fortress belonging to the 43rd Bomb Group, Fifth Air Force stationed at Port Moresby, New Guinea. Her name is from her assigned tail number 41-2666. On 16 June 1943 her "eager beavers" of "misfits and screwoffs" flew an epic mission and became the most decorated crew in American history. The pilot Captain Jay Zeamer received the Medal of Honor. The bombardier Lieutenant Joseph Sarnoski posthumously received the Medal of Honor. 
For their valor on that June 1943 flight over Buka and Bougainville, J.T. Britton, William Vaughan, Herbert "Pudge" Pugh, Forrest Dillman, Johnnie Able, Ruby Johnston, and George Kendrick were each awarded the Distinguished Service Cross, the nation's second-highest military commendation for heroism in armed conflict. This gave Old 666's crew the distinction of becoming, as it still remains, the most highly decorated combat aircrew in the history of American military service. (p. 301) [Most of the "eager beavers" also received the Purple Heart.]
Their mission was the longest running dogfight in the history of the US Air Force. For nearly forty minutes the lone B-17 fought off over twenty Japanese fighters that were using coordinated tactics for head-on attacks.  


Their photo-reconnaissance mission provided critical intelligence on the beach conditions of Empress Augusta Bay on the island of Bougainville in the northern Solomon Islands. As the authors relate at the last minute prior to taking off, mission orders changed to include the Japanese air field on Buka Island just north of Bougainville. This addition made Old 666's task a virtual suicide mission. Jay Zeamer ask his crew if they wanted to risk the Buka detour before making the run to Bougainville. To the man, they said "yes." 

Buka Air Field
The mission would have been for naught if the photos were not returned to base. The three hour ordeal of the seriously wounded pilots and crew getting the shot-up and heavily damaged bomber back to New Guinea is in itself an epic of skill, bravery and perseverance.  

Needless to say, the mission has been well documented. It's unlikely that any new information will surface on what happened that day. This book's greatest contribution is researching and telling the controversial back story on Old 666's mission. For example, it is true that when Jay Zeamer was flying his Medal of Honor mission that he had never been officially checked out to pilot a B-17. It is true that George Kendrick discovered Old 666 in the 43rd Group's boneyard awaiting stripping for parts. The plane had a "cursed" reputation of always getting shot up and nobody wanted to fly it. 

Jay Zeamer did collect his own crew of renegades who he molded into one of the best crews in the Fifth Air Force. For volunteering for every rough recon mission, they acquired the name "the eager beavers." They rebuilt the B-17 and simply "appropriated" it for their own use. Zeamer arrived in the South Pacific in March 1942 with the 22nd Bomb Group that flew B-26 Marauders. The authors have verified the story that Zeamer was transferred out of the 22nd for sleeping during a bombing run! The authors also provide fascinating background on both Zeamer's and Sarnoski's childhood and early life before the war. 

The book provides the strategic picture on the mission and why it was so important for the American offensive in the South Pacific. In this section there are a few errors that will irritate the Pacific War nerd. But, these mistakes are not really germane to the main narrative on the mission. I highly recommend this well written and researched work for anyone interested in World War II, aviation or a story of amazing heroism. 

Monday, January 22, 2018

Review: Bernard DeVoto, The Year of Decision 1846, Published 1943

Bernard DeVoto's Year of Decision 1846 is a classic work that provides a clinic on how to write a complex narrative history. He skillfully interweaves many story lines of the American conquest and initial settlement of the far west. Although considered a "popular" history, this work is thoroughly researched and provides much insight into its period. DeVoto was a part-time academic who failed in acquiring a full-time professorship at Harvard. His loss is our gain, since he devoted much of his time to writing fascinating books on the American west. 

Manifest Destiny by John Gast (1872)
The main thread of the book is the eighteen month period from early 1846 to September 1847 when General Winfield Scott's army captured Mexico City. This timeframe was the culmination of Manifest Destiny. As newspaper editor John L. O'Sullivan famously wrote in 1845 in reference to American claims on the Oregon Territory:
And that claim is by the right of our manifest destiny to overspread and to possess the whole of the continent which Providence has given us for the development of the great experiment of liberty and federated self-government entrusted to us.
DeVoto magnificently chronicles how the far west became American in his multifaceted work. He follows events by focusing on the actions of four board groups: the pioneers traveling to California, New Mexico and Oregon; the campaigns of the US Army during the Mexican-American War; political events in Washington D.C.; the attitudes of Boston intellectual types such as Henry David Thoreau. 

A significant part of the pioneer story is told through the eyes of historian Francis Parkman who spent the spring and summer on The Oregon Trail. The highlight of the settlers' story is his close following of the Donner Party. Since their story has been well documented, it does provide a detailed account on what it was like to cross the plains in a covered wagon. Contrary to current Political Correct "truth," these are the people who built America:
"I told them," Mary Graves said, "I would go too, for to go back and hear the cries of hunger from my little brothers and sisters was more than I could stand. I would go as far as I could, let the consequences be what they may."

Mary Ann Graves, twenty years old, born in Illinois of parents who had emigrated there from Vermont. An undistinguished item in the year's migration, one dot of Manifest Destiny, who had set out to find the West with her parents, five sisters, two brothers, and a brother-in-law. A person of no moment making the western traverse. The children of her children in California today are also commoners of the Democracy ... There is nothing remarkable about Mary Ann Graves, except that mankind can be staunch. "I would go as far as I could." (pp. 386-7)
She just barely made it:
Before long, four Americans [from Sutter's Fort] were hurrying back to find the six survivors whom [William] Eddy had described, and were able to find them by following his bloody footprints. The Forlorn Hope had reached the succor of their own kind, seven of the fifteen who had started out, thirty-seven days after the beginning of the effort for which they had laid in six days' rations of two mouthfuls a day. (p. 411)
Unfortunately, the Donner Party is most well-known for the cannibalism required by some members to survive the ordeal. What's largely forgotten is the epic heroism of William Eddy, William Stanton, Tamson Donner, James Reed, the delightful twelve-year-old Virginia Reed along with many others. 

Donner Party Memorial: Donner Lake California
The Mexican-American War must be one of the most lied about events in American history. DeVoto provides a lucid account of its causes and course. He doesn't sugar coat the story. For example, he makes clear his low opinion for both John Charles Fremont and General Zachary Taylor. On the other hand, he makes clear that General Winfield Scott and colonels Stephen Watts Kearny and Alexander Doniphan are among the most gifted leaders the US Army has every possessed. 

This work was originally published in 1943, which is the edition I'm using. Consequently, DeVoto is not filled with the anti-American self-loathing that animates more recent offerings on this topic. For example, he explains why the recently created state of Mexico had no valid claim to the disputed territories. He had enough objectivity and good sense to understand the Mexico was not the victim. In fact, the stupid and arrogant Mexican elite actually thought they would win a war with the United States. They were wrong and have been whining and plotting ever since 1848. 
Moreover, it is a fundamental mistake to think of Mexico, in this period, or for many years before, as a republic or even a government. It must be understood as a late stage in the breakdown of the Spanish Empire. Throughout that time it was never able to establish a stability, whether social or political. Abortive, discordant movements of revolution or counter-revolution followed one another in a meaningless succession, and each one ran down in chaos from which no governing class ever rose, or even a political party, but only some gangs. Sometimes the gangs were captained by intelligent and capable men, sometimes for a while they stood for the merchants, the clergy, the landowners, or various programs of reform, but they all came in the end to simple plunder. (pp. 12-13)  
Plus ça change, plus c'est la même chose. 

The author appears ambivalent about the figure of President James K. Polk. But, he acknowledges that he was one of the most successful presidents in American history. He deftly examines Polk's skillful handling of both Congress and the British in the acquisition of the Oregon Territory up to the 49th parallel. He also chronicles Polk's long running feuds with his senior generals who were far more political than would be acceptable in the twentieth century. 

It may appear to some readers that DeVoto spends too much time on the utopian community of Brook Farm in Massachusetts. But, these Boston Brahman dreamers provide an important thematic point for the story. It is no accident that the attitudes of these secular puritans sound very familiar.
The literary will accept no hybrid of brute and angel; they desire Utopia and will not settle for the human race. They love people but hate the mob. On George Ripley's word, and he was the founder of Brook Farm, mankind is dwarfed and brutish. In that common despair ended all that Association had to say. (p. 33)
The demented descendants of these collectivist Brahmans are more focused with their hate. The make clear their contempt for the United State and the American people - most especially white Americans. For example, in academic history it's standard practice to always write "Manifest Destiny" within sneer quotes. The actual building and existence of the American west deeply offends or triggers them. This is why there are now two large and influential groups working hard to erase America's southern border. First, there is the hostile government of Mexico City that has never accepted the settlement of 1846. Second, there are the traitors within who control the media, academia, the deep state and much else. By means of demographic reconquista, they seek to reverse the decision of 1846. 

General Winfield Scott, Washington D.C. Soon to be removed?